Post by funfun683 on May 26, 2012 1:30:15 GMT -5
Judging
Covergirl
Alisar
Catherine
Montana
Harpers Bazaar
Alisar
Catherine
Montana
Covergirl
Alisar
I think its a good photo, I wouldnt say its amazing though. I think the eyeshadow and lipstick look amazing so you sell the product really well, but I dont love the eyes to the inside. I want a make up ad to really capture my attention and that doesnt do it, I also think the lips are awkward looking.
Catherine
This is easy, breezy, covergirl! I think you really nailed the client Catherine. This shot is so soft and free, without being overtly commercial. I love the wind in the hair, your face looks amazing as always and your eyes are stunning.
Montana
This is really reminiscent of Drew Barrymores ads to me. I think you look beautiful and commercial but also with an edgy vibe. I really love the intensity in your eyes and how its strong but not overwhelming, coulda probably used more neck and had more of the focus on the make up, but well done Montana.
Harpers Bazaar
Alisar
Like your Covergirl photo, its okay but not amazing. I think that you look elegant but also strong at the same time. I think the styling screwed you over a bit because it makes you look a bit drag, but then at the same time you didnt exactly do anything particular interesting here either. I got really confused near the end of your film because you went commercial, which is fine, but totally lost the glamour and it wasnt fashion forward.
Catherine
Harpers Bazaar is such a top notch client and going through your film I felt like it looked maybe a little amatuer. Nothing really fit their aesthetic of glamorous but still sellable. I think this got the glamour part down, your face photographs amazingly like always, I think whowever did your hair should be fired though. You could have also posed in a more flattering way for your body.
Montana
I think you did the best out of the girls in finding that elegant and glamorous, but still commercial look. That being said I dont love this photo, I think of it as the best of the worst. I think you look a bit deer in the headlights, sort of like you werent expecting the camera to shoot. But you do look incredibly beautiful though, and beauty sells.